✦ Inside Speakers

Scott Hamilton
Scott Hamilton
Energy Domain

Revolutionizing Oil & Gas With Smart Tech Solutions

Energy Domain returns to PHDwin Week to showcase a client success story featuring Jordan Renner from Cosmo Energy. Learn how Energy Domain can help you as your next data partner for the Version 3 era.

Sebastian Trujillo

Director of Product Marketing, TRC Consultants LC
Sebastian Trujillo examines what AI can and cannot do in upstream reserves work, where it's moving faster than the standards built to govern it. Drawing on direct tool testing and SEC enforcement history, he gives engineers a clear framework to separate real capability from marketing claims. The engineer signs the report, not the AI.

EXPERTISE: Software Commercialization | B2B Marketing | Leveraging Generative AI and LLMs for Search Marketing

AI Can't Sign Your Reserve Report: Defensibility, Accountability, and the Limits of AI in Reserves Work

AI tools are entering upstream reserves workflows faster than the professional standards to govern them. This session provides an honest, evidence-based examination of what AI can and cannot do in reserve estimation, decline curve analysis, and economic evaluation.
The engineer’s name is on the reserve report. The AI’s is not.

Sebastian Will Cover
The accountability chain and where AI fits

Understand the legal and professional structure that breaks when AI enters the reserves workflow

Live evaluation of AI decline curve tools

Real-world demonstration of how current AI tools perform (and fail) on actual decline curve analysis

Five failure modes that disqualify AI output

The specific, reproducible ways AI-generated reserves estimates become professionally indefensible

The reproducibility problem with LLM tools

Why prompt sensitivity, model version drift, and skill-file mutability make AI output non-auditable

Ten questions to ask before trusting AI tools

A practical framework for evaluating whether an AI tool is safe to use in your reserves workflow

Who is this session for?

Qualified Reserves Evaluators, petroleum engineers, geoscientists, A&D professionals, and anyone whose name goes on a reserve estimate.

2026 Session

Qualified Reserves Evaluators, petroleum engineers, geoscientists, A&D professionals, and anyone whose name goes on a reserve estimate.

September 18

11:00 AM – 12:00 PM (CT)

35-45 Minutes

Solo Presentation

Live Streaming

Replay available after event

Sebastian Trujillo

Director of Product Marketing, TRC Consultants LC

Sebastian Trujillo is the Director of Product Marketing at TRC Consultants, where he focuses on how emerging technology, including AI, intersects with professional standards in upstream reserves work. He has conducted direct technical evaluation of AI-powered forecasting and decline curve analysis tools currently in the market, examining where they genuinely add value and where they fall short of professional requirements.

His work draws on structured review of SPE literature, SEC enforcement history, and enterprise AI deployment data, giving him a grounded view of the gap between vendor marketing claims and what these tools can actually deliver in reserve estimation, economic evaluation, and reporting workflows.

Sebastian helps reserves professionals build a practical framework for evaluating AI tools  separating genuine capability from hype and understanding where accountability ultimately rests when a reserve report is signed.

Career Timeline

Jun 2022 - Present
Director of Product Marketing

TRC Consultants, LC

Oct 2009 – Present
Founder

Empower Ecommerce LLC

Oct 2020 - Present
Venture Scout

Clearco

Licenses & certifications
Extract, Transform and Load Data in Power BI

Microsoft · Issued Mar 2025

Core Expertise

AI EVALUATION IN RESERVES WORK

Direct technical testing of AI-powered decline curve analysis tools currently in the market.

DEFENSIBILITY & ACCOUNTABILITY

The accountability chain in reserves estimation, and the failure modes that disqualify AI output from SEC filings and audits.

AI VS PROFESSIONAL JUDGMENT

A practical framework for AI assistance versus AI accountability in reserve estimation and economic evaluation.

What the Session Establishes

Seven findings from direct testing, SEC regulation, and SPE literature  and where each one leaves the engineer.

THE SIGNATURE IS NOT TRANSFERABLE

Signing a reserve report is a professional, legal, and ethical act tied to one named individual. SEC Regulation S-K requires a specific, qualified person standing behind the evaluation.

PATTERN MATCHING, NOT REASONING

Modern neural networks match patterns across tokens and vectors inside a black box. The path to any answer is difficult to fully grasp or replicate.

THE SYMBOL GROUNDING PROBLEM

An LLM relates symbols to other symbols by statistical association. Nothing in that process connects to rock properties, fluid dynamics, or pressure.

REPRODUCIBILITY FAILED UNDER TEST

Testing on the open-source CrudeCode tool returned different results from identical inputs. Non-deterministic setup, prompt sensitivity, and vendor-side updates all move the output the opposite of what a defensible audit requires.

HIDDEN DEFAULTS YOU NEVER SET

Price decks, OPEX, and discount rates hard-coded beyond the engineer's reach, quietly shaping the economics of every run.

WHERE AI GENUINELY WORKS

Purpose-built models like Chevron's Apex and Apollo, real-time geosteering and drilling optimization, artificial lift failure prediction, and parsing lease operating statements out of large repositories.

ASSISTANCE, NOT ACCOUNTABILITY

Bulk data edits, QC passes, and retrieval are real uses. None of them replace the workflow — a machine cannot hold a license, carry insurance, or answer in a court of law.

Research Sources: AI in Reserves Work

A reference document in six parts, covering SEC Regulation S-K Items 1202 and 1203 and Regulation S-X Rule 4-10, SPE-PRMS and SPEE professional standards, peer reviewed SPE papers on decline curve uncertainty and b factor behavior, published research on LLM reasoning limits and inference nondeterminism, the philosophical foundations of symbol grounding and tacit knowledge, and a file by file audit of the CrudeCode MCP forecasting application. Each entry explains how the source is used in the presentation and why it is worth reading.

Questions This Session Answers

Main Site Portal V3 Download PHDwin Support

Register For Week 2026

Complete the form below to secure your spot and be part of an exciting and unforgettable Week 2026 experience.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: . You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact